This is my second post about the data I’m getting from the Automatic device and app I use daily with my car. In the last post I tried to assess the accuracy of the mileage and fuel usage data Automatic was reporting. It turns out it’s pretty accurate. Any discrepancies appear to come when the app is unable to connect to the device for some reason. That was common early on, but less so now.
In this post, I’m trying to answer one very specific question: What are my rush hours? How early do I need to leave to “beat” rush hour? Within rush hour, are some times better than others?
My 43-mile commute is sort of a “reverse” commute. I live in Queens, NY, and work in Suffolk County, Long Island. Since I’m commuting out of the city, I face less traffic than people going in the opposite direction, but I still deal with significant traffic at certain spots. I tend to hit more traffic coming home, but it drops off significantly later in the evening so - on average - my morning and evening commutes are both around one hour.
On a typical day I arrive around 10AM and leave at 6:30 or 7:00.
The first thing I wanted to see was whether my impression that evening commutes are generally longer and less predictable is correct. This distribution of commute durations by morning and evening confirms that. As you can see, the evening commmute has a much higher density above 60 minutes, extending frequently above 80.
So, what is my rush hour? Well, first I’ll define rush hour for me. I’ll call it the period of time during which the expected time is greater than 60 minutes. If you look at the plot of durations below against departure time for morning and evening commutes, you can see a regression curve with confidence regions.
From this, my conclusion is that morning rush hour starts for me somewhere between (extrapolating) 6:30 AM and 7:30 AM and ends between 8:30 and a little after 9:00. Similarly my evening rush hour begins between 2:30 (!!!) and 3:30 and lasts until somwehere between 6:30 and 7:30. It turns out that the common wisdom around my office that you need to leave before 2 if you’re going to New Jersey is (roughly) true!
In an effort to tighten up my estimates a bit, I’d like to focus on “normal” commutes. For each trip, I also have path information, and my commutes aren’t always direct. For example, sometimes I drop my partner off at work or pick her up on the way home.
I decided to limit the analysis to commute paths that followed one of the top three routes for each direction. The top 3 routes represent 83% and 64% of trips for the morning and evening commutes, respectively.
Here are the morning and evening commute profiles for just the top three routes in each direction.
With this cleaner data set, you can see that the rush hour windows are reduced. Summarized…
|morning||6:40 - 7:20 AM||8:40 - 9:00 AM|
|evening||2:50 - 3:30 PM||6:10 - 6:40 PM|
I filtered my analysis to four routes that comprise the top three routes in each direction.
CIP-LIE - 43.0 miles
All LIE - 41.8 miles
GCP-NSP and LIE to Sag - 44.8 miles
NSP to 37A then LIE-CIP - 44.8 miles
I use the navigation app Waze on all my trips, and usually follow its route recommendations based on traffic and other incidents. So, my route is theoretically “optimized” for the shortest duration. As a result, a pattern emerges:
Here you can see that my primary route included the Long Island Expressway (LIE) and the Cross Island Parkway (CIP) in both directions. Second to that, came the most direct route (all on the LIE) - typically outside of rush hour.
Finally there were the tertiary routes, which both involved the Northern State Parkway (NSP; Queens in the morning and Suffolk in the evening). In the morning commute, this route seemed to come into play at the end of rush hour. In the evening, it looks like more of a toss up with the primary route. I can confirm that when I would look at route options in Waze the times were often within a couple of minutes of each other.
My commute is pretty predictable in the morning and the rush hours make sense. In the evening, rush hour starts earlier than I would have guessed - and trying to get out a little before 5:00 to “beat traffic” is the worst thing I can do. Rush hour is longer in the evening (no surprise), but ends a bit earlier than I would have guessed.
Also, the times involved here are interesting. While it feels like I regularly sit on the highway for close to two hours in my evening commute, the difference between peak rush hour and cruising is about 20 minutes, on average. Of course the distribution is wide, and there are definitely some painful, painful exceptions.
Commuting sucks. Thanks for nothin’ Robert Moses.
The standard data dump from the Automatic dashboard is a CSV file with one row per trip. Information about each trip includes beginning and ending times and locations, the route traveled coded as a polyline, and some data related to gas mileage. For this, I focused on times, locations and routes.
Statistical analysis was conducted in RStudio with lubridate, plyr, dplyr, ggplot2, fields and qcc libraries. I did the path analysis in an iPython notebook using a Python script from signed0. The code and related files can be found on GitHub.